Short-Seller Reports and Market Volatility: When Negative Research Leads to Securities Litigation (and When It Doesn’t)

Federal Securities laws and regulations strictly limit what a short seller may do when they are trying to call public attention to their position. The national securities litigation lawyers at Federman & Sherwood can file a lawsuit on your behalf when there has been illegal conduct.
Short sellers borrow stock and sell it in the hopes that it goes down in price. If that happens, the short seller will buy back the stock at a lower price and close the position at a profit. If the stock goes higher, a short seller has to cover the position at a loss. In the meantime, short sellers may engage in illegal conduct to drive the stock down, so they can make a profit on their trade.
When a short seller has broken the law and caused you a loss, you can fight back. Speak to the national securities litigation attorneys at Federman & Sherwood to learn what you can do in this situation. Call us today at (800) 237-1277 to schedule a free initial consultation.
Short Sellers Are Feared, and Their Words Carry Weight
Short sellers like Andrew Left (Citron Research) and Carson Block (Muddy Waters Research) have the power to move markets. In the early part of the 21st century. Jim Chanos was a feared short seller who correctly forecasted accounting issues with companies like Enron and Tyco. When they short a stock, they will publicize their own research report. Since these short sellers often have a strong track record, their words can move markets. The mere mention of a stock by any famous short seller can cause large losses for investors who own shares in the company.
Knowing that their reports and opinions can cause large drops, short sellers have an incentive to go public. Although there is nothing illegal per se about publishing negative research, there are times when this behavior can cross the line and violate securities laws. For example, in 2024, Left was charged with securities fraud by the Department of Justice for making false and misleading statements about the companies whose shares he had shorted. At the time of this writing, Left was convicted on June 1, 2026, of one count of participating in a securities fraud scheme and 12 substantive counts of securities fraud, while being acquitted of four other charges.
When Publicizing Short Positions May Be Illegal
The most obvious example of illegal conduct on the part of short sellers is the classic “short and distort” scheme that led to criminal charges against Left. Even though investors are not customers of these noted short sellers, they may still file a lawsuit when they have suffered losses due to securities fraud. Activities like those which Left has been accused of may constitute a false statement in connection with the purchase or sale of securities.
Other examples of illegal conduct that may allow you to sue a short seller include:
- Fabricating or manipulating the evidence that they use in their reports
- Trading on non-public material information
- Coordinating their actions with multiple actors who may publish negative reports in close proximity to each other
- Timing their actions to create volatility in the stock
In general, a short seller may commit securities fraud when you can prove that they have met each of the following elements:
- They made a material misstatement or omission
- They acted with either intent or Reckless disregard for the truth
- Investors relied on their statements
- Their actions were the cause of an Investor’s loss
Legal Conduct on the Part of Short Sellers
Nonetheless, not everything that a short seller does is illegal. Short selling in itself is allowed, so long as short sellers follow securities laws. As much as shareholders fear and loathe short sellers, they still perform a valuable role in the market. Further, short sellers are allowed to speak publicly because research can be either positive or negative. For example, short sellers may do the following, and it is not a violation of the law:
- Publish negative information about a company, even if their words are strong
- Analyze publicly available information and make their report public
- Disclose that they have taken a short position in a stock (this fact alone can cause a share price to drop, even without a detailed research report attached)
- Give negative commentary and criticize management
- Post on social media and appear on television or podcasts to give their opinion
As you can see, there is a fine line between legal and illegal conduct. Our securities litigation lawyers can perform a full investigation and help determine whether you have a potential lawsuit against a short seller.
Contact a National Securities Litigation Law Firm
If you have lost money because a stock you own has gone down due to illegal short seller conduct, reach out to a national securities litigation lawyer at Federman & Sherwood. You can learn more about whether you have a case, and the possible legal path forward, when you message us online or call us at (800) 237-1277 to schedule a free initial consultation.